The Ultimate Hotel Hiring Guide 2025
Updated: September 25, 2025
Who This Guide Is For
Owners, asset managers, and hiring leaders at hotels and resorts who want a strategic, outcome-driven partner to lead executive and departmental searches.
What You Will Get
-
Answers to the most pressing hotel hiring questions in 2025
-
Interview scripts, scorecards, timelines, and job post frameworks
-
Links to role-specific recruiting resources where we map, filter, and deliver candidates
Fast Navigation
Why Hotel Hiring Is Unique in 2025
The hospitality sector is recovering fast, but executive talent remains constrained. In 2025, success hinges on RevPAR growth, GOP margin expansion, guest reputation scores, and leadership stability.
How do I hire a hotel general manager in 2025?
At JDI, we begin with a five-outcome scorecard instead of generic job descriptions. We look for candidates with proven RevPAR index growth, margin improvements, guest reputation lifts, and leadership retention. Our 21-day sprint model, enriched by structured interviews and a 90-day plan exercise, surfaces operators who deliver results.
How long should it take to fill a hotel executive role?
Using our process, most placements close in 21 days, thanks to pre-blocked interviews, streamlined evaluation, and daily pipeline management. In cases of relocation or highly niche profiles, the timeline may extend to 30–45 days — but we maintain discipline and cadence throughout.
Role Snapshots & Scorecards
Each leadership role in a hotel has its own unique pressure points. At JDI, we distill those into scorecards that measure outcomes, not just responsibilities. Below are the critical roles we most often fill, with insights into what “great” looks like and how we evaluate candidates against those standards.
Hotel General Manager
What great looks like: consistent RevPAR index gains, GOP growth, strong guest reputation, and low leadership turnover.
How do I structure a hotel GM scorecard?
We design a focused, five-outcome scorecard: RevPAR index growth, GOP improvement, guest satisfaction, retention, and one property-specific objective. Anything more dilutes clarity.
[Explore Hotel GM Recruiting]
Executive Chef
What great looks like: food cost under 28%, banquet profitability, and rigorous waste control.
What is the fastest way to recruit an executive chef for a hotel?
We target chefs from properties already hitting sub-28% food cost and strong banquet margins. In our vetting process, we include menu pricing challenges to test financial acumen. Chefs who talk margin are the ones who consistently deliver.
[Explore Executive Chef Recruiting]
Director of Sales & Marketing
What great looks like: a winning group mix, pipeline health, and disciplined rate integrity.
What practical exercises should I include in interviews?
We deploy rate strategy simulations for DOSMs, 90-day plans for GMs, menu pricing exercises for Chefs, and forecast vs. actual drills for Revenue Managers. These exercises help us filter operators from storytellers.
[Explore DOSM Recruiting]
Director of Rooms
What great looks like: streamlined room readiness, housekeeping efficiency, and defect reduction that boosts reputation.
How do I assess culture fit in hotel leadership candidates?
We pose scenario questions around retention, service recovery, and cross-department teamwork. We also validate with references who confirm rehire intentions and leadership followership.
[Explore Director of Rooms Recruiting]
Director of Food & Beverage
What great looks like: outlet profitability, banquet yield improvements, upsell growth, and tight beverage cost control.
How do I avoid overpaying for hotel talent?
We tie compensation and bonus mechanics to measurable KPIs like food cost percentages, upsell revenue lift, and banquet margins. We also ensure the process is swift and transparent to prevent bidding wars.
[Explore Director of Food & Beverage Recruiting]
Revenue Manager
What great looks like: forecast accuracy, channel efficiency, and pricing tests that stick over time.
What sourcing channels work best for hotel executives?
We prioritize direct outreach to proven revenue managers in your competitive set and alumni networks. Job postings supplement only when needed — our targeted search fills these technically demanding roles faster and with higher fidelity.
[Explore Revenue Manager Recruiting]
JDI’s 21-Day Sprint Search Model
Time kills searches. That’s why JDI applies a structured sprint model that keeps momentum high and compresses the typical 60–90 day executive search down to about three weeks. We take ownership of the process so clients get results without the drag of traditional hiring cycles.
-
Day 1–3: We align the search with ownership, finalize the five-outcome scorecard, job summary, and pre-block interview availability.
-
Day 4–10: We perform targeted market mapping, outreach to competitor and alumni networks, and initial vetting.
-
Day 11–16: We coordinate structured interviews and practical exercises, evaluate performance against scorecards, and refine the slate.
-
Day 17–21: We guide final candidate selection, package offers, and lay the foundation for onboarding and a 90-day success playbook.
Most clients experience placement within this window. For roles requiring relocation or very niche skill sets, the model may flex, but we retain sprint rigor throughout.
Interview Framework & Red Flags
Interviews often fail when they’re unstructured or focused only on personality. JDI builds interview architectures that reveal whether candidates can truly move the numbers.
Our structured lanes include:
-
Outcomes: numbers, timelines, countermeasures
-
Team: hiring, training, retention examples
-
Operations: cost control, SOPs, recovery
-
Commercial: pricing, pace, mix
What interview question do we favor for GM roles?
“Tell me about a quarter you missed plan — what countermeasures did you initiate in 14 days, and what moved?” The best candidates answer with data, timelines, and direct outcomes.
Which red flags do we watch for?
Candidates who speak only stories, blame external factors without counter plans, or have repeated short tenures with vague explanations.
How do we vet culture fit?
Scenario-based questions test retention, recovery, and collaboration. We confirm with references that the candidate built real followership and would be rehired.
Compensation, Offers & Retention
Compensation is one of the first things owners ask JDI.
What compensation ranges should you expect in 2025?
Ranges vary by asset size, region, and flag. National “typical” bands (base with common bonus potential) are:
-
General Managers (GMs): $110,000–$180,000; large resort/urban assets often $200k–$240k
-
Executive Chefs: $95,000–$140,000; top-quartile hotels reaching $150k+
-
Directors of Sales & Marketing (DOSM): $120,000–$190,000; luxury and convention markets exceeding $230k
-
Directors of Rooms: $95,000–$165,000; higher in large resorts or union environments
-
Directors of Food & Beverage: $110,000–$180,000; luxury multi-outlet properties often $200k+
-
Revenue Managers: $90,000–$140,000; portfolio or regional roles reaching $150k–$175k+
How does JDI design compensation to avoid overpayment?
We anchor offers to performance metrics rather than flat payouts. By tying incentives to measurable KPIs, owners get clarity, and leaders are rewarded for outcomes.
How do we help retain executive leaders?
We set up transparent review cadences and growth paths, with bonuses tied directly to measurable wins. Hotels that adopt these structures typically see leadership turnover fall well below industry benchmarks.
How do we make your hiring process more compelling?
We accelerate decision-making: pre-block interviews, same-day feedback, and purpose-built candidate exercises. In 2025, top talent consistently chooses clarity and speed — even over the highest offer.
When is engaging JDI the smart move?
Engage us when confidentiality, speed, or specialized market knowledge are critical. We compress cycles, discreetly map competitors, and surface hidden candidates other channels cannot reach.
FAQ's
How JDI Partners With You
-
Contingent search at 25-30% of first-year salary for successful placements
-
Execution of our 21-day sprint model with your involvement as needed
-
Scorecards, interview architecture, candidate vetting, and offer orchestration handled by us
-
Nationwide coverage for hotels and resorts
Start a search: Fill Out Our Contact Form or Email Us
Explore by role:
General Manager
Executive Chef
Director of Sales & Marketing
Director of Rooms
Director of Food & Beverage
Revenue Manager