top of page
Search

CFO Hiring Guide: How to Hire a CFO Who Actually Moves the P&L

  • Writer: Jeff Schmidt
    Jeff Schmidt
  • Oct 6
  • 3 min read
Chief Financial Officer female

The right CFO is the difference between “good story, weak numbers” and disciplined cash stewardship with real flow-through. This post distills what to look for, how to interview, and when to move fast—and links you to our state-by-state CFO hiring resources and the full playbook.



Why CFO hiring is different in hospitality & clubs

Hotel, resort, casino, and club finance leaders don’t just “close the books.” They translate volatile revenue (seasonality, groups, F&B) into cash discipline, capex governance, and owner-grade communication. Great CFOs show ownership of outcomes—GOP flow-through, cash conversion cycle, covenant awareness, dues sensitivity (clubs), and F&B margin integrity—rather than a tour of roles they’ve held.


What “great” looks like (scorecard snapshot)

Use this as a calibration lens before you meet a single candidate.

  • Flow-through: Clear, repeated examples of converting revenue upticks into margin without guest-experience damage.

  • Cash & working capital: Hands-on levers for AR aging, inventory discipline, vendor terms, tip pools, and group deposit policies.

  • Capex governance: Prioritization framework, hurdle rates, and post-mortems tied to ROI—not just budget compliance.

  • Labor modeling: Forecasts that connect occupancy/banquet cadence to staffing, overtime, and cross-training tradeoffs.

  • Owner/board comms: Crisp, non-defensive narratives; risks framed with mitigations and timelines; covenant literacy.

  • Controls culture: Quietly tight processes that pass audits without freezing operations.

Pro tip: encode each of the above as a 1–5 rubric in a shared scorecard so interviewers can evaluate independently and then calibrate as a group.

The interview architecture that surfaces truth

Step 1: Focused screen (25 minutes).Two proof points only: a flow-through win and a cash discipline fix. Ask for numbers, not titles.

Step 2: Technical case (45–60 minutes).Mini P&L with RevPAR swing, banquet margin wobble, and a payroll spike. Look for levers, not theory.

Step 3: Panel interview (45 minutes).Ops + Finance + HR. You’re testing for cross-functional trust and clarity under pressure.

Step 4: Working session (60 minutes).Candidate leads a capex/board update using your real (sanitized) pack. You’re listening for prioritization and tradeoff fluency.

Step 5: Back-channel references. Ask for a time they said “no” to a popular capex and were right.

Case prompts you can copy

  • “Group business surges but F&B margin slides three points. Walk me through the investigative path and the first two fixes.”

  • “Capex requests exceed budget by 40%. How do you stage approvals over 12 months, and what dies?”

  • “Debt covenant headroom shrinks. What operating levers do you pull before revisiting lender terms?”


Red flags (don’t rationalize these)

  • “We” language with no personal agency.

  • Variance narratives without countermeasures and deadlines.

  • Over-indexing on audit/control theater while ignoring guest or ops realities.

  • Can’t teach the P&L to a non-finance peer.


Compensation & structure (principles that travel well)

  • Tie bonus gates to cash and flow-through, not just revenue.

  • Use milestone-based retention for transformation agendas.

  • Equity or phantom-equity should reward end-state value creation, not tenure.


State-by-state CFO hiring resources

Use the table below to jump to localized CFO hiring pages—market signals, timelines, and nuances by state.


When to start a CFO search (signals)

  • You’re hitting top-line goals but GOP won’t stick.

  • Overtime and contractor spend drift without clear owner.

  • Capex queue feels political instead of ROI-based.

  • Lender meetings feel reactive, not proactive.


What you’ll find in the full CFO Hiring Guide

  • A ready-to-use scorecard (the rubric leaders actually rally around).

  • A complete interview kit (screening, technical case, panel, working session).

  • Reference questions that surface real ownership vs résumé tours.

  • A 90-day plan template tied to cash, flow-through, and guest experience.



FAQ: CFO hiring for hotels, resorts, casinos, and clubs

How is a hospitality CFO different from a corporate generalist? They manage margins in a service environment with daily demand swings, staffing volatility, and capex cycles that directly affect guest experience. Operators trust them because they solve real tradeoffs, not just enforce rules.

What’s the fastest way to evaluate a CFO candidate? Run one technical case with a RevPAR swing and an F&B margin dip, then a working session using your actual board/owner pack. Look for clean levers, timelines, and risk framing.

What metrics should drive the bonus plan? Cash conversion and GOP flow-through first, supported by labor discipline, inventory turns, and covenant headroom. Revenue alone creates perverse incentives.

Where should a hospitality CFO spend their first 30 days? On labor and cash: overtime patterns, group deposit policies, AP cadence, and vendor terms. Then align capex staging to guest-impact priorities.

When do you reject an otherwise likable candidate? If they can’t demonstrate personal ownership of 2–3 measurable wins—with numbers, timeframes, and countermeasures—they’ll narrate the business instead of driving it.



Need a short-list calibrated to your P&L and ownership structure? Start a search

bottom of page